I tested some of the best tubing mascaras available, rating each option on its formula, brush type, staying power, and more. I also consulted two makeup artists to finalize my picks and learn more about tubing formulas. The picks recommended here are the ones that are worth your mo

We can’t say enough good things about the ILIA Limitless Lash Lengthening Clean Mascara . It has a super long wand to reach even the smallest hairs, while delivering lengthened, curled lashes with every swipe. No smudges, easy to remove. Mic drop. A close second is the Tower28 MakeWaves Mascara that offers a beautiful curl thanks to the curved wand, a weightless feel, and a flattering pigment that bui

Top Product Picks: Ellis Faas Lights in Dark Metal, Ellis Faas Eyeliner in Black, Ellis Faas Hot Lips Lipstick in L407, Cle de Peau Beaute Radiant Fluid Foundation, Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow Volumizing Eyebrow

Misha Shahzada is a celebrity makeup artist based in New York City.

Alyssa Kaplan is an editor on Byrdie, an experienced writer in the beauty industry, and a product tester specializing in cosmetics. She has been using and testing lip stains for many years, trying nearly 15 options in search of those that last all day and don’t dry out her lips. Alyssa received a bachelor’s degree from the Fashion Institute of Technology, where she studied marketing and product development in the cosmetics industry as well as fashion business marketing. She has been at Byrdie since 2022, where she covers all things bea

Our favorite mascara is the Benefit Cosmetics Fan Fest Fanning Mascara . It helps curl and lift while separating and volumizing the lashes for a gorgeous, full look and wears well without smudging or flaking. If you’re looking for a foolproof drugstore buy, we recommend the Maybelline Sky High Mascara . It lengthens and separates the lashes beautifully, remaining intact all day l

It’s never fun to pass by a mirror and spot a smudge of mascara under your eye, notes our tester (we couldn’t agree more). She was happy to report that this smear-free, lengthening formula stayed perfectly clean all day. Though not marketed as "waterproof," it definitely acts as a long-wear product. The tubing formula felt light and comfy on her lashes, and the bristle brush—which narrows at the tip—allowed her to grab those pesky inner-corner lashes. Her favorite perk was how lifted and extended her lashes for hours. Don’t get heavy-handed, as she says one to two coats is all you need. To take off the tubes, she used a few swipes of remover (and one nail on a clump). It can also be washed off with just water and fing

Beware not to apply too many coats or it could clump (two quick coats are sufficient), and don’t get it in your eye (it can be irritating). Her favorite part, besides the flattering brown hue, is how well it held up—even with teary e

If you’re after major drama or a curl that lasts, prep with a curler first, or the lift may soften over time. When it’s time to wash up, you’ll need proper makeup remover to take it off, she confirms, and then you’ll be left with a nice, clean sl

Our tester appreciated how this formula created a natural-looking, precise definition that lasted all day. The weightless texture felt like nothing on her lashes and didn’t bother her chronically dry eyes. She appreciated how dense the brush is, ideal for covering and grabbing those little, sparse lashes, but it did cause some clumping and smudging (notably on the lower lash line). We also appreciate that it’s seamless to remove, whether you use warm water or makeup games Cheats|https://Makeupinsight.com/ remov

Leave it to Lancôme to keep innovating in the mascara category; the brand has been creating top-tier mascaras for decades. Their newest addition to the line is this lengthening pick, featuring a long, narrow brush that's easy to control, making it ideal for targeting hard-to-reach lashes. When testing this one, I couldn't get over how seamlessly it applied; the brush combs the formula through the lashes without clumping them together, and helps give them a lift by getting so close to the lash line. One coat gave me gorgeous length and definition, while a second coat added just a hair more dr

It’s rare to find anything under $10 these days, and this high-performance, drugstore mascara is one of them. The tubing formula, made with jojoba oil to nourish lashes, comes in three shades: soft black, pitch black, and deep brown (so if you like more subtle hues, there are options). Our tester found it ideal for anyone with short, fine lashes looking for length and clean separation, thanks to a comb that grabs even the tiniest hairs. She was able to build it up smoothly with two to three coats and zero clu

What's the difference between a lip stain and lipstick?

According to Shahzada, lip stains and lip tints are a cross between a gel and a cream, designed to have longer wear than traditional lipsticks. "I usually consider them a hybrid of lipstick and gloss but with more longevity," she expla